Having Just read the Can Robots be Trusted article in the February 2010 edition of Popular Mechanics (why it is a month ahead when it is only now January 15th I have no idea), I find myself thinking on all of the different sci-fi renditions we have been inundated with over these last few years. Even though the article debunks what most people fear, the extinction of humanity at the hands of a cold logical machine, I cannot help but wonder if we may slip down that road anyway.
For me the first things that come to mind (much like the articles author) are movies like The Terminator, 2001, where logical and self-aware A.I., take drastic measures to protect themselves and eradicate the humans who threaten them. It strikes at the heart of one of our deepest fears; betrayal of our creations. Do we deserve the fate so ominously heralded? Or is there way out?
Battlestar Galactica deals with this in its story with a possible solution given by, of all characters, Ellen Tigh, “We wanted to warn the colonies about creating Cylons, We wanted to tell them ‘keep them close’...but we were too late. The war had already begun”.[1] The idea was to care for and appreciate that which we create in order to have the trust we need to interact socially. The article presents the idea that one thing that may allow this is that we as humans will react positively to a robot “...if you have the robot behave and move in ways that are known to enhance trust and engagement the reaction is the same as it is with people.”[2] This, at least, gives us some hope.
So what of the rights of the creation from the creator? We have seen this argued in sci-fi forums like Bladerunner, Star Trek, I-Robot and others over the years. Will we have the moral fortitude to give equal rights to these creations or will we fall into the pit the 12 Colonies and the Tyrell Corporation? Herein lays the conundrum when it comes to machines: if we have the right to create do we have the right to destroy them. The obvious argument being it is a machine and does not have life. We must somehow quantify what life is, but are we then not stealing fire from the gods? Likening ourselves to god in our arrogance and determining what life is and is not? There is a whole other can of worms both ethical and spiritual.
[1] Battlestar Galactica Season 4 Deadlock.
[2] Can We Trust Robots, Popular Mechanics Feb. 2010, pg. 60.